What You Should Know Before Buying a Rental Property: The Pros, Cons & Hidden Factors
Owning a rental property can seem like an easy way to build wealth, but behind the scenes, there are trade-offs and hidden factors that many investors don’t realize at first glance. Here’s a breakdown of the key pros and cons—including the ones you might not have considered.
(see also our article on “The Benefits of Owning a Rental Property” related to this post)
1. Retirement Income: Passive, But Not Effortless
✅ Pro: A rental property can provide long-term passive income, helping to fund your retirement beyond your pension, RRSP, or savings. It can even allow for early retirement if managed well.
❌ Con: “Passive” doesn’t mean effort-free. You’ll still need to handle maintenance, inspections, tenant concerns, and unexpected repairs—even in retirement.
Hidden Factor: If you’re relying on rental income for retirement, make sure to factor in vacancy periods, property taxes, and potential rent control laws that could limit your income growth.
2. Cash Flow: More Than Just Rent vs. Mortgage
✅ Pro: A tenant essentially helps pay off your mortgage while you build equity. A well-financed rental can even generate monthly profit.
❌ Con: Financing can be tricky. A bad mortgage rate, high property taxes, or an unplanned major repair can wipe out your profit for months.
Hidden Factor: Property values and rental demand fluctuate. If you buy at the wrong time or overestimate rental income, you could struggle to break even. A real estate agent and financial advisor can help ensure your investment is truly profitable.
3. Family Time: Your Property Might Own You
✅ Pro: A rental property can be a family asset, teaching kids about real estate and even allowing them to contribute with simple tasks like mowing the lawn or painting. It can give you additional income which could allow for more family time.
❌ Con: Emergencies don’t wait for weekends. Late-night plumbing issues, tenant disputes, or surprise inspections can take time away from your family and personal life.
Hidden Factor: If you plan to self-manage, set clear boundaries and have a backup plan for handling issues when you’re unavailable. Otherwise, hiring a property manager may be worth the cost.
4. Income Diversification: A Safety Net—With Risks
✅ Pro: Rental properties can provide a stable income stream even during economic downturns. A good tenant can mean steady cash flow, even if you lose your job.
❌ Con: Tenants can miss payments or suddenly move out, leaving you covering the mortgage until a new tenant is found.
Hidden Factor: Unlike stocks or other investments, real estate is not liquid. Selling a property in a downturn or in an emergency can be time-consuming and costly. Be prepared for financial ups and downs.
5. Long-Term Wealth: Slow and Steady Growth
✅ Pro: Real estate is one of the few investments where you can leverage bank financing to grow your wealth. Over time, rental income can pay off the mortgage and leave you with a fully owned asset.
❌ Con: Real estate requires patience. Unlike stocks, you can’t cash out instantly. Property values don’t always rise as expected, and maintenance costs increase over time.
Hidden Factor: Many landlords underestimate property depreciation and ongoing costs. Set aside a fund for repairs and upgrades to keep your investment valuable in the long run.
Is a Rental Property Right for You?
A rental property can be a fantastic investment— but only if you’re prepared for the hidden costs, time commitment, and financial risks. Before jumping in, do the math, consult experts like real estate brokers (preferably who have been in your market for a long time), and be honest about how much time and energy you’re willing to put into it.
Want help deciding? We’re here to help too if you’re looking at investing in rental properties. Send us an email for more advice on the process by selecting “Investment Opportunities” or “Rent Value” to get a market appraisal from one of our licensed property managers!
Want more helpful property tips? Visit our blog!
